@manofmatter @sean_t_barry @HarmKnoops And, follow-up: when you talk about the history of #ALDep, what do you say? Still cite only #Suntola, like Chem. Rev. 2010, 110, 1, 111–131 https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R Or did you already update your views on #ALDhistory?
In addition to generally #VPHA, I told my personal story, related to the dual discovery of #ALDep. A link is made to my #JAP2005 review https://t.co/yhK4qC8ce7. (And @GeorgeGroupCU review from 2010, https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R. And the 2002 book chapter from @
@Complex_Henrik Thanks! - Found one more: "CVD contribution". George 2010 review, https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R
@GeorgeGroupCU
(Notice for example that what is currently the most cited review on #ALDep https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R, published five years after my review https://t.co/yhK4qC8ce7 that exposed the two early branches of #ALDhistory, does not mention a word of molecular layeri
As said, the path to publication of #JAP2005 was not easy. The path included a blunt rejection from a referee, who did not see really any value in the review, as written. The contrast with the value seen later by the field, through citations, is striking.
First, on the impact. Here is a screen capture of the numerical metrics of the article of today, from AIP’s website https://t.co/qQBw0z8i4y. Cited > 1600 times, according to WoS. My most cited paper and the 2nd most cited review on #ALDep (1st: George,
Now: six #ALDep review recommendations in the above-mentioned list, as the George 2010 review was just added (recommendation by me), https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R. More recommendations welcome! #ALDepChat @GeorgeGroupCU
@sean_t_barry @HelsinkiALD ... After our discussions (in Dec?), I searched a little on this. The sources I (quickly) encountered which presented #ALDwindow as a region of constant GPC, pointed as reference to https://t.co/KZ1bygH20R - now the most cited #A
@GeorgeGroupCU A link to the George review, too: https://t.co/VKNaRni572